<$BlogRSDUrl$>
Second Balcony
Non-immanent critiques

Hyperbole of the week

Monday, October 03, 2005
It's not just that nobody writes rock lyrics as good as Dan Bejar's ('Destroyer') these days. It's that nobody writes poems as good as Dan Bejar's lyrics these days.
I remain agnostic on the question of the comparability of poetry and songs, though. Worst case scenario, this is like claiming that this year's apples are much better than this year's oranges, which is perfectly valid. Just buy or download a Destroyer album, ideally "Your Blues" or "City Of Daughters". This is a good as it gets, and as good as one could ever have hoped that literary rock to be. It delivers what Cale's "Paris 1919" heralded thirty years ago and no worthy successor followed: Modernism with an electric guitar.

There are many , many other ways for rock to be great, and to be of high artistic merit ,and to have great writing, but I'm talking about one specific path , along which many talents went far, intentionally or unintentionally, but which no one quite completed until now. What we had were either flawed versions (mostly flawed by naivety of some kind, which denies the Modernism trophy no matter how supreme every other aspect of the writing is), or versions perfect and complete on their own right but askew from this particular point of view:

We had Stephin Merrit's literary genius filtered through a fascination with camp and kitsch, Dylan's great literary talent diluted by his stupidity, Jonathan Richman's inimitable precision and wit delivered only through an idiot mask, Reed's inspiration narrowed and flattened by a childish Beat ethos, Bowie's genuine intuitive poetic greatness ruined by intellectual posing and a lack of education to match it, Frank Black's genuine intuitive poetic greatness limited by a lack of intellectual posing, Malkmus' near perfection deflated by a lack of ambition. Destroyer is the real thing.

Obviously, I really don't dig Joshua Clover's/Jane Dark's conception of a complete and utter divide between pop music and high-art. The fact that a rock song doesn't have to have high-art merit doesn't mean it can't, doesn't mean it shouldn't and doesn't mean that if it does we should ignore that aspect of it. This is like writing a defense of the pleasure and value of a really nicely structured murder mystery, concluding that Agatha Christie is valuable even though her work does not posses high-art literary qualities, and derive from this that we shouldn't look for high-art literary qualities in Ecco's and Borges' detective fiction, and not compare them to such writers as Calvino and Thackery (random choices), because their pleasures are of a different kind.

The creation of a specialized value system to judge the low-brow too often comes with a fatalist exclusion of the possibility of a work possessing different aspects and thus having merits of both kinds, or, what is *much* more common, its elements being multi-functional, and its different kinds of merit dependent upon each other ('The aggressive guitars build a huge energetic pathos which both empowers the Brechtian satirical lyrics and is Ironized by their implications, and still make you want to jump around and dance, though with a sense of guilt ' , which would make a true observation about an Israeli band called Habiluim).

There's also the Naturalistic Fallacy based argument, that pop songs are presented in a certain way, inviting a consumption very different than that of high-art (I'm using the vulgarized sense of Naturalistic Fallacy here, obviously. But as the vulgarized sense is a private case of the proper case, I'm indulging). It can be attacked in three slightly different fronts, each making the others redundant:

First to the Naturalistic Fallacy : the fact that they are consumed in a certain way does not mean that a new way to consume sine of them may not be a better way, and in this case I can think of no obvious prescriptive bridging principal to makeit so that the normal way of consumption as the right one. This argument is wrong for the same reason the descriptive argument again The Death Of The Author is wrong (except as an argument against the bad, descriptive parts of Death Of The Author).
To go back to my detective fiction analogy, the fact that Chandler was marketed as pulp, doesn't mean Auden did bad by offering to read him as serious fiction. A critic's role (rather than just be an evaluator) is to actively change: to recognize potential and help expose it. If a songs can supply high-art pleasures, no reason in the world not to go mining for it.

Secondly , the argument is proven wrong by the very fact of it needing to be given - if people try to judge pop songs by high art standards, and seek high art pleasures in them, apparently, their mode of presentation is not so confining as to make it unthinkable, and their consumption not predetermined.

And last, this argument is factually wrong: pop songs have a double, triple, quadruple life.
The MTV2 hit alt-hit of three years ago that existed in the public eye for a week and was gone may also be the song I've been listening to in a loop for three days last month, and the one whose lyrics I will discuss with a friend ten years from now. I've been wondering about the interpretation of "Perfect Day" for two years now, and "Perfect Day" is also played at weddings as a romantic song. People jump around drunkenly to the same songs they will listen to at home wide eyed with a cuo of tea, admiring its craftsmanship and transcendental beauty. Some song people only jump around drunkenly to, some you only listen to with a cup of tea an supreme consentration, and some songs only live on MTV2 as the alt-hit of the week. But the multi-functionality is already there and manifest, not just as a potential for multiple kinds of pleasure, but actually as multiple kinds of pleasure.


Say no to critical a-priori pre-packaging of artistic effects which don't actually come with a package. And listen to Destroyer.
10:15 AM :: ::
<< Home
Peli Grietzer :: permalink